I don’t usually dabble in news blogging. After all, you’re talking to the guy who not once, not twice, but three times asked three different guys how their respective fiancees were doing, only to find out they’d broken up a few weeks before and still weren’t over each other. I typically hear my news from the guys who are usually the last to find anything out. Nevertheless, there is one news item out there that is being spoken about nation-wide (I was listening to the Russ & Lisa show for some strange reason this evening - they’re local Greenville folks, and they were talking about it) that happens to hit three issues very close to my heart: English as a national language, Philly, and Cheesesteaks (which hits physically pretty close to one’s heart, depending upon how many one consumes). So when a news item comes up that I can get three quick venting points out of (yes, bad grammar - sue me), I’m pretty happy to give it a go.
Let’s talk about the actual facts here. At the risk of sounding like every talk show host on the East Coast, the media’s not giving you the whole story.
Fact: Joey Vento, owner of Geno’s Cheesesteaks in South Philly, has a sign placed at his ordering window that reads: “This is America. When ordering, please speak English.”
Fact: He also has a second sign, in a completely different style, that reads: “Management reserves the right to refuse service.”
Fact: These signs are atop one another, but not connected to each other - they are two separate signs, not just one. The “Management refuses…” sign was up long before the “Speak English” sign went up.
Fact: The city is pretty divided on how they feel about this.
All right - first point is private business. Our Constitution says that the government (and by extension, the governed) may not discriminate on the basis of nationality, age, race, blah blah blah. The media spin on this one goes like so: He said Mexicans walk up and can’t say “Cheeze Wiz.” He has a sign saying “Speak English.” He has another sign about refusing service. Therefore, he will refuse service to anyone who doesn’t speak English. Therefore he’s being a discriminating pig, so let’s sue the tar out of him.
If you were nodding the whole way through that, you probably have less intelligence than a slice of proscuito. There are several leaps of “logic” that throw the whole thing into spin city. Starting at the backend, reporters in California assume he refuses service to non-English speaking people. He himself says he doesn’t, and that’s confirmed by bunches of customers, none of whom have been turned back. Next, those two signs aren’t necessarily (or actually) related. All businesses have the right to refuse service for their own reasons. Even if the English thing were a factor, he’s still got that right. By refusing people who speak any language other than English (and more languages exist than just English and Spanish, peeps) he’s not discriminating based on race. Suppose I’m Mexican, and I speak passable English. If he were banning non-English-ordering customers, I wouldn’t get banned. That one example alone confirms that he’s not discriminating against an entire national heritage.
But all this assumes he’s refusing people orders for not speaking English. Without any evidence to the contrary, I don’t think we can argue that. Taken at face value, two things are going on. With the first sign, he’s proclaiming his right to refuse service to people who are giving his workers a hard time, disrespecting something about him or the establishment, being disruptive, etc. All businesses have that right; he’s just confirming it in print. With the second sign, he’s making a political statement - this is America, and if you want to fit in, you should learn American.
Enter the intrepid City Council, who (like so many left-wing PC nuts) have decided to get offended on the behalf of the not-offended-but-should-be people. Apparently immigrants are either too illiterate or too stupid to take offense at being “discriminated against,” so it’s up to the smarter, more literate folks to be offended for them. (I’m being facetious, FYI.) Your Southpaw spin says that “these signs could offend immigrants who haven’t learned the language” (putting aside the fact that, if you can’t read the English sign, you can’t be offended by its content; and if you can read it, there’s no reason to get offended by its content) - consequently people with very Latino names are thinking of taking him to court. (Did I mention these people with Latino names speak flawless English? Just an observation.) This is, by the way, the same city that showed brotherly love for a guy who killed a cop just because the killer had a fake Arabic name. He was black and had a fake Arabic name! That must mean he’s not guilty! It’s also the same city that re-elected a mayor who was, at the time, under investigation by the FBI for a whole mess of charges, simply because the mayor claimed he was being oppressed by white people. So this whole mess with Geno’s is actually normal, in an abnormal sense.
Another neat fact is that he’s a 3rd generation Italian immigrant himself. It wasn’t until his grandparents started attending school that they had to learn English to actually get an education. If you’re more on the lebanon bologna side of the IQ scale, you’d probably see this as proof positive that immigrants should learn English. If you’re more on that proscuito side, you’d think that naturally it makes no sense for him to be complaining about immigrants not learning English when that’s exactly what his grandparents did. And if you just reread that sentence three times, scratched you head, and said, “What…?” then you’re smarter than a lot of folks. Hey, don’t take this “immigrants must learn English” stuff from me - my ancestors immigrated in the 1500s. Take it from him, who knows what it’s like to go around not knowing what anyone else is saying. Only difference is that now, the immigrants are telling us that we have to change for them.
Bottom line: Rush Limbaugh theorizes often that the liberals in this country need victims to survive, and that their survival instinct demands that they keep the victims in their current state, or else make new ones. This concept of being offended on behalf of people who clearly aren’t offended fits right in there. Personally, I agree with the guy completely. I think it’s better for immigrants in the long run to learn English so they can actually live the traditional American dream, which is NOT to sit at home all day, watch soap operas, and collect welfare checks to buy more Corona. I agree that he has a right to run his business as he pleases, provided he’s not violating any laws. And I agree that his place is the original home of the Cheesesteak.
Stay tuned for more updates and general mocking of the morons running that wonderful town.